emailaddr.jpg










About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on November 29, 2006 8:10 PM.

The previous post in this blog was Spanish Police Torture Terrorist.

The next post in this blog is Don't Shoot the Messenger.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Blogs We Read

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Powered by
Movable Type 3.33

« Spanish Police Torture Terrorist | Main | Don't Shoot the Messenger »

Jiminy Cricket He Ain’t

If the New York Times can’t call it right on child porn, no wonder they have no compunction compromising anti-terror measures by printing state secrets. Mitch Wagner, of InformationWeek, blogs this:

If an IT Manager Finds Kiddie Porn on President’s Computer, Should He call the Cops?

That's a question posed to the New York Times's "The Ethicist" column. The columnist, Randy Cohen, has a completely insane response: The IT manager should remain silent.

The questioner writes: "I am an Internet technician. While installing software on my company’s computer network, I happened on a lot of pornographic pictures in the president's personal directory, including some of young children — clearly less than 18, possibly early teens. It is probably illegal and is absolutely immoral. Must I call the police? I think so, but I need my job."

The Ethicist responds:

It is a crime to possess child pornography, and understandably: the sexual exploitation of children is reprehensible. Yet you have no legal obligation to contact the police, nor should you. The situation is too fraught with uncertainty. These photographs might depict — legally — not children but young-looking adults. The images could be digitally altered. Your boss may have acquired free (albeit illegal) images rather than bought them and provided a financial incentive to those who harm children. Someone other than your boss may have downloaded the pictures.

The link is behind the iron curtain of Times Select. Most likely to hide the column; it certainly isn’t because the advice is worth paying for.

Since when was the standard for ethical behavior, other than during the Clinton administration, drawn at whether something was legal or not? Ethical behavior is about right and wrong. I would say that Randy Cohen doesn’t have a clue but I don’t believe that. He knows. So does the questioner – he is just looking for someone to validate his wrong choice. Maybe that’s why he finds Times Select worth the price.

UPDATE: What answer would Mr. Ethics give if the question was "If an IT Manager Finds Kiddie Porn on a Republican Congressman's Computer, Should He call the Cops?

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.uncorrelated.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/1210

Comments (1)

Mick Stockinger:

Stunning. Absolutely stunning.

Unfortunately, this kind of confusion about ethical behavior is, in my view, pervasive in the liberal establishment. Years ago, there was a vigorous debate over private and public ethics within the liberal community. I found it amazing that such a debate was at all necessary.

The thing I think a lot of liberals are confused about is the nature of ideals. Our inability to live up to our ideals don't obviate their value, yet this is precisely the liberal view--I can't live the rules, so the hell with them...

Post a comment

(This site no longer requires authentication for unmoderated comments to be posted immediately. Simply enter your comment with a valid email address and type the challenge word into the field below before posting. UNCoRRELATED accepts no editorial responsibility for the comments posted here, but will by discretion, remove vulgar, abusive or commercially-motivated comments. You may receive email notification of follow-up comment by clicking on the Subscribe to this entry checkbox.)





Tom-Mannis.jpg thinkingblogger.jpg









Google PageRank 
Checker - Page Rank Calculator

Blogroll Me!

Powered by FeedBurner

Add to Google Reader or Homepage

Subscribe in NewsGator Online

Subscribe in Rojo

Add UNCoRRELATED to Newsburst from CNET News.com

Add to My AOL

Subscribe in FeedLounge

Add to netvibes

Subscribe in Bloglines

Add to The Free Dictionary

Add to The Free Dictionary

Add to Plusmo

Subscribe in NewsAlloy

Add to Excite MIX

Add to netomat Hub

Add to Webwag

Add UNCoRRELATED to ODEO

Subscribe in podnova

Add to Pageflakes